St Johnstone 3
Ayr United 3 (4-5 on pens)
Scottish Challenge Cup (Quarter Final)


St Johnstone 

3 - 3

Ayr United


Scottish Challenge Cup (Quarter Final)
Tuesday, February 17th, 2026
Falkirk Stadium
Attendance: 999


Goalscorers
Josh McPake (pen.) (30)
Liam Smith (89)
Jamie Gullan (90)
George Oakley (15)
George Oakley (29)
Kevin Holt (47)

Team Managers
Simo Valakari Scott Brown

Starting Eleven
1. Toby Steward
3. Cheick Diabate
4. Morgan Boyes
14. Matty Foulds
15. Jack Baird
7. Jason Holt
11. Sam Stanton
19. Taylor Steven
24. Josh McPake
18. Ruari Paton
27. Alfredo Agyeman
Max Thompson .31
George Finney .55
Liam Dick .3
Kevin Holt .5
Scott McMann .33
Leon King .20
Stuart Bannigan .6
Mark McKenzie .22
Ben Dempsey .8
George Oakley .9
Anton Dowds .7

Bench
20. Ross Sinclair
2. Reghan Tumilty
33. Liam Smith
35. Adam Forrester
8. Jonathan Svedberg
10. Jamie Gullan
22. Stevie Mallan
46. Fran Franczak
21. Kai Fotheringham
Liam Russell .38
Kenzie Mitchell .25
Shaun Want .4
Nick McAllister .2
Jude Bonnar .17
Jamie Hislop .18
Ethan Walker .21
Lucas McRoberts .29

Substitutions
Kai Fotheringham for Josh McPake (46)
Jamie Gullan for Ruari Paton (46)
Stevie Mallan for Jason Holt (46)
Jonathan Svedberg for Sam Stanton (63)
Liam Smith for Alfredo Agyeman (72)
Nick McAllister for George Finney (46)
Ethan Walker for George Oakley (75)
Jude Bonnar for Anton Dowds (80)

Cautions
None. Ethan Walker (90)

Red Cards
None. None.

Match Officials

Lloyd Wilson (Referee)
Dan McFarlane & Lloyd Wilson (Assistants)



Photography by Dave Sargent

Match Report


Despite producing a late comeback Saints were narrowly beaten on penalties this evening as their KDM Evolution Trophy campaign came to an end against Ayr United.

George Oakley fired the Honest Men into a two-goal lead after 28 minutes however, Josh McPake pulled a goal back from the penalty spot after he had been fouled by George Finney to give Saints a lifeline before the break.

Ayr restored their two-goal cushion just two minutes into the second half when Kevin Holt turned home a Stuart Bannigan free kick. Saints refused to fold, though, and set up a dramatic finale. Liam Smith pulled a goal back with a fine right-footed effort before Jamie Gullan took the match to penalties, reacting quickest to slot home the rebound after his initial spot-kick had been saved by Max Thompson.

In the shoot-out, Stevie Mallan saw his effort kept out by Thompson as Ayr moved 2-1 ahead after two penalties each. Toby Steward produced a vital save to deny Mark McKenzie to keep Saints hopes alive, and with the sides locked together after five kicks apiece, sudden death was required. There, Matty Foulds was denied by Thompson which sent the Honest Men through to a semi-final tie against Inverness CT.

Played at Falkirk due to the game being postponed 3 times.

Match report written by St Johnstone FC Web



Squad Statistics (as at February 17th, 2026)


2025-26 All Time
Age
Max Thompson (GK)21 2 - 2 -
Kevin Holt33 264264
Liam Dick30 23 - 23 -
George Finney18 5151
Leon King22 211211
Scott McMann29 321732
Mark McKenzie25 32722624
Stuart Bannigan33 23 - 485
Ben Dempsey26 21314719
George Oakley30 1676423
Anton Dowds29 2246427
Nick McAllister (sub)25 2221325
Jude Bonnar (sub)20 241241
Ethan Walker (sub)27 244489






League Table (as at February 17th, 2026)


Pld W D L Pts
1. St Johnstone 24 14 7 3 49
2. Partick Thistle 24 12 8 4 44
3. Arbroath 24 10 7 7 37
4. Ayr United 23 7 11 5 32
5. Morton 25 6 12 7 30
6. Dunfermline At 23 8 5 10 29
7. Raith Rovers 25 7 8 10 29
8. Queen's Park 23 5 9 9 24
9. Airdrieonians 25 5 8 12 23
10. Ross County 24 5 7 12 22