One Game Wonders All Competitions
| Name | Nation | Game | |
 |
Ellis Hare Reid | 
|
07/09/2019 (Scottish Challenge Cup) Ayr United 1-1 Wrexham |
 |
Peter Urminsky | 
|
27/02/2021 (League) Ayr United 0-1 Arbroath |
|
|
David Waite |
|
16/08/2017 (Scottish Challenge Cup) East Stirlingshire 1-5 Ayr United |